If you’re anything like me, finding the perfect gift can sometimes feel like staring into a dark forest without a flashlight. That’s why I’ve put together this list of 10 supernatural graphic novels that I believe will thrill, chill, and entertain anyone lucky enough to unwrap them this year. Graphic novels are fantastic because they combine captivating storytelling with stunning artwork, making them great gifts for both seasoned readers and newcomers alike. Whether you want to spook your friends, inspire your kids to read more, or just impress the comic lover in your life, these picks have something special.
So, let’s dive into the strange, eerie, and often hilarious worlds waiting in these pages.
Top Picks
How I Picked These Graphic Novels
I chose titles that offer a mix of supernatural themes, compelling storylines, and striking artwork. Priority was given to novels with strong reader reviews, accessibility for different age groups, and originality in the supernatural genre. I also looked for stories that bring humor and heart alongside the scares, plus titles with diverse characters and immersive worlds.
Price, availability, and whether the graphic novel had a unique twist on familiar supernatural tropes also played a role in the selection. Basically, if it made me chuckle while raising the hairs on the back of my neck, it earned a spot.
The Haunted Mask
If you grew up with Goosebumps or are just looking for a spooky graphic novel that’s actually fun to read, this one’s a solid pick. Honestly, because Goosebumps played such a major role in my younger self becoming addicted to horror, I couldn’t not have this in the #1 spot. My soul simply refused. This edition follows Carly Beth, who’s tired of being the scaredy-cat and bullied kid, so she grabs this seriously creepy Halloween mask that’s supposed to make her scary too. Trouble is, the mask has a mind of its own and won’t come off easily. The artwork blends creepy and comical perfectly, making it a great read for kids and anyone nostalgic for ’90s Goosebumps vibes.
Whether you’re grabbing it for a late Halloween read or just want a quick supernatural fix, it fits right in your everyday or special spooky occasions. I’d say, add it to your shelf if you like a mix of scares and laughs.
What People Say
People often mention how the art amplifies both the scary and fun parts of the story, making it super engaging. Fans appreciate how true it stays to the original while giving it a new twist with the graphic novel format.
🗣️ Gianni R.
This is a classic Goosebumps tale brought to life for a new modern generation. The illustrations are both comical and creepy, and it’s very faithful to the original. Highly recommend for readers who like a good scare with some gross humor.
🗣️ Carsanna M.Buckley
Loved the nostalgic vibes. The graphic novel style gave the story a fresh look and the art really nailed it. Perfect for fans of the original and a great read for kids who like spooky and funny.
Why It Feels Good
It’s like revisiting a childhood favorite but with fresh surprises. You’ll get that cozy ‘remember when’ feeling while enjoying spooky chills and laughs. Great for sharing with kids to pass down the Goosebumps tradition.
Why It’s Fun
The mix of scares, clever humor, and those classic Goosebumps twists make it a page-turner. You’ll find yourself flipping through quickly, hooked on what the mask will do next – and maybe doubling back to appreciate the artwork that balances spooky and silly.
Why I Like It
- Faithful adaptation of a Goosebumps classic story
- Great mix of creepy and comedic artwork
- Perfect for kids and nostalgic adults alike
- Easy and engaging read for Halloween or anytime
Rating: 4.8 (total: 169+)
Paper Girls: The Complete Story
This graphic novel threw me right back to the late ’80s, following a group of kids who start their paper routes and stumble into a time-bending mystery. While I LOVE the author, it wasn’t until the Amazon show that this one hit my radar. While I wish the live-action series hadn’t been cancelled, this one honestly is just a better read. I love how it mixes everyday childhood stuff – friendships, first jobs – with wild sci-fi twists that keep you guessing.
Whether it’s for casual reading or as a gift for someone who loves a bit of nostalgia and supernatural shenanigans, it’s a pretty great all-around pick. The story feels complete and satisfying, so you can dive in without worrying about cliffhangers or needing to track down dozens of volumes.
What People Say
Readers often highlight how the blend of ’80s details and sci-fi elements keeps the story both grounded and thrilling. The depth given to each character really helps the story resonate beyond just the supernatural happenings.
🗣️ Andres Mercedes
This story managed to give me nostalgia and perspective at the same time! Every character is fully developed, every story thread neatly tied up, every page engaging and purposeful. Brian K Vaughn is my absolute favorite comic book author, so if you like his other works, you’ll like Paper Girls!
🗣️ TheMogget
The art does a great job selling the story and setting the mood with easy-to-follow details of the late ’80s. The writing really shines though – the characters and their interactions grew on me big time, and their innocence is heartbreakingly real. By the end, I was totally attached.
Why It Resonates
It hits that sweet spot between warm nostalgia and wild adventure, reminding us of childhood friendships and the magic hidden in the ordinary. There’s this bittersweet feeling that stays with you, like looking back at when things were simpler but full of secrets.
Why It’s a Blast
Flipping through the pages, you’ll find a fantastic mix of thrilling twists and perfect ’80s vibes – from hairstyles to bikes to the overall spirit. The pacing keeps you hooked and the art pops with color, making it a genuinely fun ride every page of the way.
Why I Love It
- A fully wrapped-up, complete story perfect for binge-reading
- Brilliant mix of nostalgia and mind-bending sci-fi
- Rich, relatable characters you quickly root for
- Art and colors that vividly bring the era and mood to life
Rating: 4.8 (total: 1100+)
Nimona: A Netflix Film, A Graphic Novel
I dove into Nimona expecting a quirky fantasy tale and found so much more. It’s this fun mix of medieval knights, dragons, and surprising science-y twists wrapped up in a story about friendship, identity, and fighting what’s ‘supposed’ to be true. (I’ve since watched the Netflix adaptation and have to say, they did do a good job!)
Nimona, with her unpredictable powers and mischievous attitude, teams up with Lord Blackheart to stir the pot – opening doors to some seriously complex relationships and moments that hit right in the feels. This is a perfect pick whether you want to casually chill with something heartfelt or gift someone who loves stories with a little bite and a lot of charm.
What People Say
Readers often praise the way Nimona combines quirky humor with deeper themes about identity and friendship. The dynamic between Nimona and Lord Blackheart feels fresh and compelling, and many mention the art style as both vibrant and expressive.
🗣️ Laura Liisa
I had such a great time reading this graphic novel! The medieval-meets-tech vibe and strong character relationships made me care deeply about the story. Plus, there were plenty of amusing bits that felt like pure gold. The ending left me wanting more but satisfied. Definitely a wonderful book!
🗣️ Tonja Drecker
Picked this for my 8th grader and we both enjoyed it a lot. The story is easy to follow but packed with tension, humor, and surprisingly deep moments. The fantasy elements felt fleshed out and the unexpected ending sparked great discussions. A really solid addition to any graphic novel collection.
Why It Feels Personal
This graphic novel hits that sweet spot where you’re laughing one moment and genuinely moved the next. It’s about more than heroics – it’s about finding where you belong and who you can trust, all wrapped up in a wild and unpredictable story.
What Makes Reading It a Blast
Nimona’s wild shapeshifting antics, paired with the biting wit throughout, make this a genuinely fun read. The mix of medieval knights and surprising tech elements adds a playful twist that keeps things exciting and unpredictable.
What Makes Nimona Stand Out
- A unique blend of fantasy, science, and sharp humor
- Relatable, well-drawn characters with complex relationships
- A story with surprises that keeps you hooked from start to finish
- Beautiful full-color art that enhances the mood and story
Rating: 4.7 (total: 6030+)
Stranger Things: The Other Side
I picked up this graphic novel because, well, who doesn’t love Stranger Things, right? It takes you right back to season one but through Will’s eyes, exploring the spooky Upside Down in vivid detail. The art by Stefano Martino is top-notch, making those creepy creatures almost jump off the page.
Jody Houser’s writing captures Will’s voice perfectly – he’s still the thoughtful, loyal kid we adore, even when facing the frightening unknown.
What People Say
Everyone I know who’s read this has said the same thing: ‘It’s like the show, but with extra Will!’ Fans appreciate the insider look at his scary journey and how it connects the dots we never got in the series. Some say it’s a bit short, but hey, quality over quantity in my book!
What This Graphic Novel Gave Me
Reading this felt like catching up with an old friend who just happens to be trapped in a terrifying alternate dimension. I found myself rooting for Will all over again, feeling a mix of nostalgia, suspense, and a little kid-like wonder at the sci-fi twists.
The Thrill Factor
I won’t lie – flipping through these pages gave me that satisfying ‘just one more chapter’ vibe. The story moves briskly, the artwork keeps you hooked, and it’s just packed with those supernatural surprises Stranger Things fans crave.
Why I Loved It
- Official canon story that fills in cool gaps from the show
- Stunning artwork that really brings the Upside Down to life
- Perfect blend of nostalgia and supernatural chills
- Great for fans who want more Will-centric action
- Clean enough for younger readers but still thrilling
Rating: 4.7 (total: 2,058+)
Five Nights at Freddy’s Trilogy
I’ve always been curious about the spooky lore behind Five Nights at Freddy’s, and this boxed set pulls you right into that eerie world. Mainly, because my eldest was obsessed with the idea series for years, and I kind of wanted to read through and make sure it was appropriate for him when he was a bit younger. It follows Charlie and her friends as they stumble back into Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza on the anniversary of a chilling tragedy. The mystery unfolds with just the right amount of suspense and horror, but it’s also about friendship and uncovering secrets.
The art brings those creepy animatronics to life in a way that’s spooky but totally gripping. Whether you’re a longtime fan or just want a supernatural graphic novel that doubles as a great gift, this set delivers on every page.
What People Say
Readers consistently praise how well these novels captivate younger audiences without losing the dark, creepy charm of the FNAF universe. Parents love that it holds their kids’ attention and even gets friends talking. Plus, the solid print quality and thick pages make it a gift that feels substantial enough to impress.
🗣️ jamie bennett
My son is a FNAF fanatic. He loves everything to do with these books and it’s a great price.
🗣️ bzymom65
Kids love these books. My 9-year-old has read and reread them multiple times and even shared with friends. They keep advanced and casual readers hooked.
The Emotional Ride
There’s this weird mix of nostalgia and suspense that keeps me hooked – like revisiting a scary childhood memory but feeling braver this time around. It’s the kind of story that makes you want to peek behind every door and maybe sleep with a nightlight on.
What Makes It Fun
Flipping through this trilogy, I found myself laughing, gasping, and solving little puzzles along with the characters. It’s got that classic ‘one-more-chapter’ magic that makes binge-reading impossible to resist.
Why It’s Worth Reading
- Complete trilogy in one handy boxed set
- Engaging storyline that blends mystery with supernatural thrills
- Artwork that brilliantly captures the creepy vibe
- Characters you actually care about in the middle of chaos
- Perfect for sharing with friends who love spooky tales
Rating: 4.9 (total: 1,195+)
The Woods Vol. 1
This graphic novel tosses a whole prep school into an alien forest, and things go sideways in all the best ways. What I love is how it mixes the survival mystery with typical teenage drama, so it feels both epic and oddly relatable.
Whether you’re curled up on a regular Tuesday or need a gift that sparks curiosity and conversation, this one hits the mark. The artwork pulls you right into that eerie wilderness, while the story keeps dropping enough clues and twisty moments to keep you hooked throughout.
What People Say
Readers consistently highlight how the mysterious plot pulls them in and how the artwork is stunning, almost like its own character. People are hooked on the mix of teen dynamics and surreal sci-fi that makes this more than just another graphic novel.
🗣️ Jensensdad
I love the story and artwork. Fantasy/Sci fi/ Lord of the Flies story. Mr. Tynion has outdone his previous works. Give it a shot.
🗣️ troublef
I love this series. The story is good, but the real star is the art and the colors. I like to just pull it out and flip through it for inspiration.
The Feels Behind the Adventure
There’s this oddly nostalgic vibe when you see high school cliques try to survive in a hostile world, and it taps into that anxious but thrilling feeling of being completely out of your depth. It’s like revisiting awkward teenage years but with monsters lurking around every corner.
What Keeps You Glued In
Between the unexpected twists and the detailed visuals, it’s hard not to keep turning pages. Plus, if you’re like me, you’ll get a kick out of spotting little story clues hidden in the background art or guessing which character’s about to cause more drama.
Why You’ll Want to Read It
- A captivating mix of sci-fi mystery and high school drama
- Beautiful, realistic art and rich color work
- Story hooks you with twists and character dilemmas
- Perfect for fans of eerie, atmospheric tales like Stephen King
- Great starting point for a wider series filled with suspense
Rating: 4.3 (total: 452+)
Poe: Stories and Poems
Diving into Edgar Allan Poe’s classics can be a bit intimidating, right? This graphic novel by Gareth Hinds breaks down those eerie tales and poems into stunning artwork paired with accessible storytelling.
It’s perfect whether you’re looking to introduce younger readers to Poe or just want a fresh way to enjoy those gothic hits like “The Raven” or “The Tell-Tale Heart.” The visuals really bring out the mood – think shadows and whispers on every page – making it a great companion for both solitary reading nights and sharing spooky stories at gatherings. Plus, the author’s notes add a neat layer of context without feeling like a textbook.
If you’re after something atmospheric, a little dark, but totally engaging, this book fits the bill.
What People Say
Readers love the faithful yet approachable retelling that lets Poe’s dark genius shine through artfully. Many appreciate the added context from notes and thematic icons, which make following the stories easier and more meaningful.
🗣️ Jillian C
This adaptation brings Poe’s moods to life with beautiful watercolor and pencil art. I especially liked how the stories stayed true yet were easy to follow, making it great for teens and adults alike. The author’s notes at the end added cool insights about each story’s history.
🗣️ Gianni Breck
I’m a big fan of Poe and graphic novels, so this was right up my alley. The illustrations really set the tone, though I wish the stories were a bit longer. Still, it’s a solid way to get kids interested in Poe, especially with the helpful theme checklists and glossary notes.
The Mood It Sets
There’s an eerie but inviting vibe that pulls you into Poe’s world, making the chills feel just right instead of overwhelming. It sparks curiosity and a little thrill every time you turn the page, perfect for tapping into that love of gothic mystery.
What Makes It Hard to Put Down
Between the mix of creepy tales and gorgeous paintings, you’re always discovering new details – like hidden symbols and subtle emotions on characters’ faces. It’s like a puzzle and a story, making the reading experience fun and engaging, not just spooky.
Why This Graphic Novel Works
- Captures the haunting spirit of Poe’s stories and poems
- Stunning watercolor and pencil illustrations that set the mood
- Includes helpful thematic warnings and author’s notes
- Accessible for young adults while still engaging for older readers
- Great for classroom use or casual binge-reading on spooky nights
Rating: 4.8 (total: 1015+)
Monstress Volume 1: Awakening
Monstress Volume 1: Awakening throws you into a richly detailed world brimming with magic, war, and complex characters. I found the combination of steampunk and art deco alongside manga-inspired art totally captivating.
Maika, our fierce protagonist, is on a tough journey juggling her inner monster and brutal past, which makes this graphic novel feel more like a haunting epic novel than just your average comic. It’s great for those moments when you want to get lost in a new world or for special gifting – this one reminds me of a dark fairy tale with a touch of beautiful chaos.
If you enjoy stories that mix gothic fantasy with deep emotions and stunning artwork, this is a no-brainer to pick up.
What People Say
Readers appreciate the breathtaking artwork and the deep, immersive storytelling. Many note the dark themes handled maturely alongside a visually stunning presentation that makes it stand out.
🗣️ melanie (meltotheany / jtotheimin)
I loved everything about this graphic novel. The story, characters, and art blew me away. It’s dark, complex, and its art—wow—constantly made me pause just to stare. Definitely a masterpiece that stays with you long after reading.
🗣️ Amazon Customer
Interesting mix of steampunk, horror, and manga. The watercolor art adds incredible depth, and while the story can seem confusing at first, it invites you to think for yourself instead of spoon-feeding everything. I’m hooked on the potential of this series and eager for more.
The Feel Behind the Pages
Monstress grips you emotionally with its atmosphere of mystery, trauma, and resilience. It’s the kind of story that sticks with you, making you reflect on themes of identity and survival long after closing the book.
What Keeps Me Hooked
Between its gorgeous, detailed visuals and the layers of story packed into every page, you’ll find yourself re-reading just to catch what you missed. Plus, there’s a touch of dark magic that keeps things thrillingly unpredictable.
Why I Love Monstress
- Intricate world-building blending steampunk, magic, and mythology
- Stunning watercolor art with manga influence that draws you in
- Strong, complex female characters driving a dark, compelling story
- A rich narrative that feels immersive and layered like a novel
- Great for fans of dark fantasy and storytelling with emotional depth
Rating: 4.6 (total: 2875+)
Something is Killing the Children Vol. 1
Something is Killing the Children Vol. 1 immediately pulls you into a creepy little town where kids are disappearing, and the usual adults just don’t seem to get it.
Erica Slaughter, the badass stranger who shows up, is the only one who sees the monsters and isn’t afraid to face them. What I love here is the mix of horror with real emotion – the townsfolk’s grief feels raw, and Erica is a refreshing kind of hero who knows what she’s about without all the usual ‘screaming and disbelief’ drama.
Whether you want something thrilling for a quiet night in or a standout gift for your horror-loving friends, this graphic novel nails that spooky vibe with compelling storytelling and atmospheric art that sticks with you. Plus, it balances mystery and action perfectly – you get enough answers to stay hooked but still crave the next volume.
What People Say
Readers can’t get enough of Erica Slaughter’s complex character and the way the story respects the horror genre without relying on clichés. The pacing and atmosphere have earned plenty of praise for being both terrifying and emotionally engaging.
🗣️ Deb S
This graphic novel packs a punch with its plot and keeps you hooked the entire way. The artwork perfectly complements the story, especially the intense eyes of the characters. Can’t wait for the next one!
🗣️ Kat & Jin
James Tynion IV has crafted a uniquely spooky horror comic with a no-nonsense female lead who actually gets things done. The story leaves enough mystery to make it way more chilling and the brutal scenes aren’t just gore for gore’s sake.
Why It Hits Home
There’s a real sense of tension and vulnerability throughout that pulls you in – it’s not just about the monsters but about how people deal with loss and fear. Erica’s empathy and grit make the story resonate on a surprisingly human level.
What Makes Reading a Blast
The mix of thriller-style storytelling and dynamic art layouts really brings the horror scenes to life. It’s the kind of story that makes you want to keep flipping pages late into the night, guessing what’s coming next without feeling overwhelmed.
What Makes This One Stand Out
- A fresh take on horror with a strong, relatable female lead
- Gripping story that balances mystery, action, and emotional depth
- Artwork that sets a dark, immersive mood without going overboard
- Perfect for fans of horror and supernatural graphic novels
- Ends on a cliffhanger that makes you want to dive right into the sequel
Rating: 4.7 (total: 2547+)
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina: Occult Edition
This oversized hardcover edition of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is like stepping into a shadowy, thrilling world where high school drama meets supernatural danger. Sabrina’s at a crossroads on her 16th birthday, torn between her mortal life and a darker destiny. While this one was a bit too YA for me (as was the Netflix show), I did get the appeal and can see why it is a good read and watch for many!
The story mixes the occult vibe with everyday teenage struggles in a way that feels fresh and compelling. The artwork by Robert Hack nails the creepy atmosphere perfectly, so it’s great for chilling nights or as a unique gift for someone who loves a spooky, well-crafted tale. Whether you’re a longtime Sabrina fan or new to the saga, this book offers a rich combo of horror, mystery, and character moments that keep you turning the pages.
What People Say
Fans appreciate the blend of horror and teen drama, praising the creepy yet beautiful art and well-developed characters. People who grew up with Sabrina find this series a fresh, edgier revival that still feels true to the character.
🗣️ Albion Dragon
Apart from the dark production photos in the extras, this book is great. The art perfectly sets the creepy tone and the story is gripping and well-written. Definitely worth picking up if you like Sabrina’s spooky side.
🗣️ Anon
This is a brilliant comic, though heads up, the series isn’t finished yet. Still, the story and art make it worth reading, and I hope they wrap it up someday. For now, it’s a thrilling ride.
The Feel-Good Chills
This graphic novel draws you into Sabrina’s world with a genuine sense of suspense and emotional complexity. It’s not just witchcraft and scares – it’s about tough choices and growing up, making you root for Sabrina even as dark things unfold.
Why It’s a Blast to Read
Flipping through the pages feels like binge-watching a dark cult series. The mix of eerie visuals and a story full of twists keeps things exciting without overwhelming you.
Perfect for enjoying some supernatural thrills with friends or solo reading.
Why You’ll Love It
- A fresh, darker take on Sabrina that’s perfect for fans of horror and supernatural stories
- Striking artwork that creates a moody, atmospheric experience
- A coming-of-age story that balances magical intrigue with relatable teen dilemmas
- Includes extras like behind-the-scenes images and old Archie comics for added depth
- Hardcover format makes it a cool collectible or gift
Rating: 4.7 (total: 331+)
FAQ
Are supernatural graphic novels appropriate for all ages, or should I be cautious when gifting them?
Ah, the age-old question of whether the spooky stuff is kid-friendly! Honestly, it depends on which novel you’re eyeing. For example, The Haunted Mask (Goosebumps Graphic Novel #1) is perfect for kids 7 and up – it’s got that creepy-but-not-nightmare-inducing vibe and a sprinkle of gross humor that kids can handle.
On the flip side, titles like Monstress Volume 1 or Something Is Killing the Children Vol. 1 are definitely geared toward teens and adults due to darker themes like violence and complex storytelling. So, if you’re gifting, check the recommended reading age to avoid any midnight puppet shows that come with terrifying screams.
We’ve got you covered either way, so you can pick the perfect spooky story for little ghouls or mature monster hunters.
How can I make sure the graphic novel I buy will be a hit with the recipient, especially if they’re new to the genre?
Great question! When in doubt, I always suggest starting with something that’s not just spooky but also super engaging with strong characters and clear storytelling – like Nimona.
It’s got humor, heart, and shapeshifting antics that hook newbies without overwhelming them. Also, consider the recipient’s age and interests: if they love retro vibes, Stranger Things: The Other Side is like a comfy sweater of nostalgia; if they prefer deep, fantasy worlds, Monstress offers a richly layered experience (but be warned, it’s a lot!).
Sometimes, sneak a peek at reviews or preview pages online to judge the art style and story flow. And hey, if the person’s a fan of a show or movie adaptation – like with The Haunted Mask or Chilling Adventures of Sabrina – that’s a guaranteed win!
Wrapping Up
After exploring these ten supernatural graphic novels, it’s clear that the genre has something for everyone. From the nostalgic scare of The Haunted Mask to the rich, complex worldbuilding in Monstress, these novels blend art and narrative in ways that pull you deep into strange and thrilling experiences. Gifting any one of these will not only entertain but invite the reader into a world where the supernatural is just a page turn away. Whether you’re shopping for a kid who needs some encouragement to read or a friend who craves dark humor wrapped in fantastic illustration, this list covers all bases.
So, take it from me – these graphic novels make a memorable and exciting gift choice in 2025.
